data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/013c8/013c8b192b3d4b8fd4bcb81d43c0da2b7f6b1c16" alt=""
I'm not really a fan of "The Guard". It was certainly entertaining and
reasonably funny but it was also deeply derivative; it often felt like
something John Michael McDonagh's more talented brother Martin might
have thrown out as not quite up to the mark. "Calvary", McDonagh's new
film, is a considerable improvement, if again not wholly successful. For
a start, it doesn't feel remotely 'realistic' but then, I hear you ask,
why should it be. Realism is not necessarily a prerequisite for a
successful drama but this film feels 'scripted', full of stock
characters teetering, and sometimes falling over, into cliche. What
McDonagh has given us here isn't so much a realistic drama but a
parable, a passion play set over the course of a week in which a kind of
Christ figure, (in this case, a 'good' priest), waits for his own
Calvary which he knows is coming.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a60d0/a60d0b795ab4264935946ca36285b1731aedc200" alt=""
It begins in the confessional when
someone we don't see tells the priest, (Brendan Gleeson), that he will
kill him a week on Sunday. The would-be murderer's reason for this is
two-fold; as a child he was repeatedly raped by a priest now dead and
secondly, why kill a bad priest? Isn't it a much greater affront to an
uncaring God to kill a good priest, a man who is totally innocent?
McDonagh
is reputed to have said that this is his 'Bresson' film and yes, there
is something Bressonian about the hell that Gleeson is living in, for
here is a rural Irish community that could have come out of Dante and
have been drawn by Bruegel. There are drug addicts, a rent boy,
adulterers, disbelievers, even a child murderer, all well played but
none particularly feasible, (it's hard to accept that a policeman who
openly avails himself of the services of a gay rent boy would slap a
priest in the pub or that a priest would start firing a gun around a bar
and then get beaten up by the barman). If you can't believe in the
characters then it is hard to accept the initial premiss.
Still, if
this film is something of a failure it's an honest and an ambitious
failure. The last ten minutes or so are quite devastating and Gleeson,
as always, is superb. (Stand-outs in the supporting cast include Chris
O'Dowd's cynical wife-beating butcher and Dylan Moran's drunken
land-owner). As to who the potential killer is, McDonagh keeps us
guessing to the end, throwing in the customary red-herrings to
side-track us on the way. It's a film I believe has been overpraised and
yet there isn't much else like it out there at the moment. See it and
judge for yourselves.