Luminously photographed by Marius Panduru in the now unfashionable
Academy ratio, Romanian director Radu Jude's superb new movie "Scarred
Hearts" is based on the writings of Max Blecher and deals with the time
he spent in a sanatorium on the Black Sea. The year is 1937 and
Blecher's alter-ego is Emanuel, suffering from Pott's Disease, a form of
TB. Though not an asylum, the hospital is something of a madhouse.
Operations are performed with the minimum of anaesthetic, if any, and
the doctors have no qualms in telling the largely manhandled patients
exactly what's wrong with them and everything, including sex between the
patients, seems to be permitted. Emanuel suffers more than most but
bears it all stoically, even managing to fall in love with a former
patient, and there is a good deal of humour in the film. Lucian Teodor
Rus, making his screen debut, is excellent as Emanuel, even if he does
spend most of the film on his back and Serban Pavlu is superb as his
doctor. I'm sure for many people a two and a half hour film about
illness might seem something of an endurance test but Jude makes even
the grimmest passages seem somehow life-affirming. A wonderful picture.I have been reviewing films all my life, semi-professionally in the past and for the past 10 or 12 years on imdb and more recently in letterboxd and facebook. The idea of this blog is to get as many of those reviews gathered together in one place. I have had a great deal of support and encouragement from a lot of people throughout the world and I hope that continues. Now for the ratings. **** = not to be missed. *** = highly recommended. ** = recommended. * = of interest and no stars = avoid..
Friday, 2 August 2019
SCARRED HEARTS ****
Luminously photographed by Marius Panduru in the now unfashionable
Academy ratio, Romanian director Radu Jude's superb new movie "Scarred
Hearts" is based on the writings of Max Blecher and deals with the time
he spent in a sanatorium on the Black Sea. The year is 1937 and
Blecher's alter-ego is Emanuel, suffering from Pott's Disease, a form of
TB. Though not an asylum, the hospital is something of a madhouse.
Operations are performed with the minimum of anaesthetic, if any, and
the doctors have no qualms in telling the largely manhandled patients
exactly what's wrong with them and everything, including sex between the
patients, seems to be permitted. Emanuel suffers more than most but
bears it all stoically, even managing to fall in love with a former
patient, and there is a good deal of humour in the film. Lucian Teodor
Rus, making his screen debut, is excellent as Emanuel, even if he does
spend most of the film on his back and Serban Pavlu is superb as his
doctor. I'm sure for many people a two and a half hour film about
illness might seem something of an endurance test but Jude makes even
the grimmest passages seem somehow life-affirming. A wonderful picture.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment